"Art is art. Everything else is everything else." - Ad Reinhardt
He was a critic of abstract expressionism. Reinhardt’s earliest exhibited paintings avoided representation, and show a steady progression away from objects and external reference. He is best known for his Black paintings of the 1960s.
"... I think Ad Reinhardt is possibly the best artist in America ... Reinhardt's abstract art is pure and religious. It flies away from all naturalism, from all representation ... " - Merton, 1940, "Run to the Mountain, page 128
In the spring of 1959 Lax and Reinhardt visited Merton at Gethsemane. In his thank you note, Reinhardt says to Merton:
"... let's argue about art and religion some more. If you're doing a book on it, and you have a world-wide audience, can I help you say what's right, instead of saying things people want to hear and agree with? You just make people happy if you don't say what's right, true (beautiful?) ... thanks for the weekend."
In fact, in 1962 Merton was taken with the art of William Congdon, an American painter, abstract expressionist and devout Catholic who focused on religious themes. Merton wrote a few paragraphs praising Congdon's work, and threw in a line condemning abstraction:
"... here the dynamism of abstraction has been set free from its compulsive, Donysian and potentially orgiastic self-frustraion and raised to the level of spirituality." - Thomas Merton, jacket copy for William Congdon, In My Disc of Gold: Itinerary to Christ of William Congdon, 1962Well, Reinhardt soon caught wind of this and fired off to Merton a blistering letter, taking him to task for his poor judgement.
" ... I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw ... Why shouldn't you be human after all ... have you given up on hope? Have you no respect for sacredness and art? ... Are you throwing in the trowel at long last? Can't you tell your impasto from a holy ground? ... We'll send help, hold on, old man." - Ad Reinhardt letter to Merton, 1962Merton had the good sense to listen to Reinhardt's criticism. His reply, though superficially humerous, shows that Merton and Reinhardt were looking at each other, eye to eye, and this was a time of reckoning.
"Dear Ad,Merton decisively moved to Reinhardt's camp and the world of contemporary art. As an artist, he would not go back to his drawings of Our Lady. As an author, he would not turn medieval concepts to a task for which they were not suited.
"Once, twice, often, repeatedly, I have reached out for your letter and for the typewriter. Choked with sobs, or rather more often carried away by the futilities of life, I have desisted ...
"Truly immersed in the five skandhas and plunged in avidya, I have taken the shell for the nut and the nut for the nugget and the nugget for the essence and the essence for the such-ness ... I have embraced a bucket of schmaltz. I have accepted the mish mash of kitsch. I have been made public with a mitre of marshmallows upon my dumkopf. This is the price of folly and the wages of middle-aged perversity. I thought my friends would never know ... I am up to my neck. I am in the wash. I am under the mangle. I am publicly identified with all the idols. I am the byword of critics and galleries. I am eaten alive by the art racket. I am threatened with publication of a great book of horrors which I have despised and do recant." - Merton letter to Ad Reinhardt, 1962
Like Lax and Reinhardt, Merton headed into the Unknown.
Ad Reinhardt died on August 30, 1967, of heart problems. He was 53 years old.
As a memorial to Reinhardt, Merton published in the first issue of his literary magazine, Monk's Pond, a chantlike text by Reinhardt, dating to 1962. Here is one verse of that text:
"The one object of fifty years of abstract art is to present art-as-art and as nothing else, to make it into the one thing it is only, separating and defining it more and more, making it purer and emptier, more absolute and more exclusive - non-objective, non-representational, non-figurative, non-imagist, non-expressionist, non-subjective. the only and one way to say what abstract art or art-as-art is, is to say what it is not." - Ad Reinhardt, Monk's Pond 1, Spring 1968, p. 6 first published in Art International, December 1962
Sounds like God, doesn't it?
See also - does art have anything to do with life? (Robert Lax on Ad Reinhardt)